Earlier this year, we wrote about a series of unusual manoeuvres by the Supreme Court in three significant cases: the recall in the Bhushan Steel insolvency, the modification in the Allahabad judge’s matter and the larger bench reference in the Delhi stray dogs matter. At the time, the apparent randomness of those decisions felt like the story.
The last week of Chief Justice B.R. Gavai’s tenure makes the earlier chaos appear less random and more like a new judicial playbook, one in which the finality of a signed judgement seems increasingly negotiable and the question of relief depends on who is asking. We write again not to offer a full reckoning of his tenure, but because it is striking, and perhaps telling, that these final-week retreats come under his leadership. It cemented what had already begun to emerge: a legacy of judicial undoing.